Garden Bed Math

🧭 Garden systemZones9 stepsFree working copy

Garlic planting in zones 3 to 5: wait for the frost, then plant

Quick answer

In zones 3 to 5, garlic goes in after the first fall frost. Minnesota Extension says one or two weeks after the first killing frost, and Wisconsin says the same. Look up your typical first frost and add 7 to 14 days. At the St. Paul station that's October 15 to 22. A 4 x 8 ft bed at 6 inches each way takes 128 cloves, or 16 to 22 heads. Set them 2 to 3 inches deep, pointed side up, and cover the bed with 3 to 4 inches of straw or shredded leaves that week.

Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026; University of Kentucky Extension, October is garlic planting time, checked October 8, 2026; NOAA 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals, annual/seasonal, checked October 7, 2026.

Updated October 9, 2026 Sources checked October 9, 2026 Print the working copy

A northern garden in late October with garlic being planted into a bed, frosted grass and a bale of straw

Decide first

Should you plant garlic this fall?

Do it yourself

Plant it yourself

If you have a sunny bed you won't need until next summer, this is one afternoon in October plus a bale of straw. Garlic stays in the bed all winter and comes out the next summer.

Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026.

Skip it

Skip it if the bed is needed in spring

Fall garlic holds the bed through spring. If you want it for early crops, use another bed. Iowa State lists late March to mid-April as a spring planting time, but Maine's bulletin says spring garlic doesn't reach the size of fall garlic.

Source: Iowa State Extension, When should I plant garlic?, checked October 8, 2026; University of Maine Extension, Bulletin #2063 Growing Hardneck Garlic in Your Maine Garden, checked October 9, 2026.

Get help

Ask your county extension office

For varieties that do well in your county, or if the plants look wrong in spring, call your county Cooperative Extension office. This page covers dates, counts, mulch and the bed layout, not plant problems.

A filled-in cold-zone garlic bed plan for zip code 55108 GARLIC BED PLAN, ZONES 3 TO 5USDA zone 5a StationU of MN St Paul, 0.6 mi, NOAA 1991 to 2020 FIRST FALL FROST 1 in 10 earlierSep 25 TypicalOct 8 PlantOct 15 to 22 THE BED Inside size4 x 8 ft Spacing6 in each way Depth2 to 3 in THE ORDER Cloves128 Heads16 to 22 Seed garlic2.6 to 3.6 lb Mulch the same week: 3 to 4 in of straw or shredded leaves, 8 to 10.7 cu ft for this bed. Plant week = typical first frost + 7 to 14 days (Minnesota and Wisconsin: a week or two after it). The same plan from September to May SepOctNovDecJanFebMarAprMay Septemberlook up the frost date Sep 251 in 10 first frost Oct 8typical first frost Oct 15 to 22plant and mulch Apr 28typical last frost: mulch off or kept Summer: Wisconsin harvests when about half the leaves have turned brown. Write the date in the log.
A filled-in cold-zone garlic bed plan for zip code 55108 in St. Paul, Minnesota: NOAA 1991 to 2020 frost dates, the bed, the order and the mulch, then September to May on one line.

September to look up, one October afternoon to plant

The steps, in order

  1. Look up your first fall frost

    Type your zip code into the frost date lookup and write down the typical first fall frost and the 1 in 10 earlier date. For zip code 55108 in St. Paul, the station about half a mile away gives October 8 and September 25.

    Have ready: Your zip code. Do it in September, before the seed garlic arrives.

    Frost date lookup by zip code

    Source: NOAA 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals, annual/seasonal, checked October 7, 2026.

  2. Add one to two weeks

    Count 7 and 14 days from the typical date. For St. Paul that's October 15 to 22. Minnesota and Wisconsin say a week or two after the first killing frost but give no temperature for one, so we use the typical 32°F date as the marker.

    Have ready: The frost date from step 1 and a calendar.

    Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026; NOAA 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals, annual/seasonal, checked October 7, 2026.

  3. Measure the bed and count the cloves

    Measure inside the boards and type the size into the garlic calculator at 6 inches, the spacing Wisconsin gives. A 4 x 8 ft bed takes 8 rows of 16: 128 cloves.

    Have ready: A tape measure.

    Garlic and bulb planting calculator

    Source: University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026.

  4. Order heads or pounds

    At Kentucky's six to eight cloves a head, 128 cloves is 16 to 22 heads. At Maryland's 6 to 7 large hardneck heads a pound with 6 to 7 cloves each, that's about 2.6 to 3.6 pounds. Wisconsin says hardneck types do best where winters are long.

    Have ready: The clove count. If the seller lists cloves per head for the variety, use that number.

    Source: University of Kentucky Extension, October is garlic planting time, checked October 8, 2026; University of Maryland Extension, Garlic, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026.

  5. Get the straw before the frost

    For 3 to 4 inches over a 4 x 8 ft bed you need 8 to 10.7 cubic feet. Wisconsin asks for clean straw. Maine lists dried grass, leaves or straw.

    Have ready: The bed size. Stack the bales or bags next to the bed.

    Mulch calculator

    Source: University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026; University of Maine Extension, Bulletin #2063 Growing Hardneck Garlic in Your Maine Garden, checked October 9, 2026.

  6. Split the heads on planting day

    Wisconsin and Maine both say to separate the cloves just before planting. Plant the largest cloves, since Wisconsin says they generally grow the largest bulbs. Keep the small ones for the kitchen.

    Have ready: A bowl for the planting cloves and another for the small ones.

    Source: University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026; University of Maine Extension, Bulletin #2063 Growing Hardneck Garlic in Your Maine Garden, checked October 9, 2026.

  7. Plant 2 to 3 inches deep, 6 inches apart

    Set each clove pointed side up with its base 2 to 3 inches below the surface, as Minnesota says. Wisconsin warns that cloves planted too shallow can be injured in winter and early spring. Start 3 inches in from the boards so the outer rows fit.

    Have ready: A stick marked at 3 and 6 inches.

    Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026.

  8. Mulch the same week

    Spread 3 to 4 inches of straw or shredded leaves over the whole bed. Minnesota says this evens out winter and early spring soil temperatures and helps with weeds.

    Have ready: The straw from step 5.

    Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026.

  9. Decide on the mulch in spring, then log the harvest

    Minnesota and Wisconsin take the mulch off once the risk of hard freezes is over; Minnesota also lets you leave it on. The typical last frost at St. Paul, April 28, is a late marker for that. In summer Wisconsin harvests when about half the leaves have turned brown. Write both dates in the log.

    Have ready: The printed bed plan, kept with the seed box.

    Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026; NOAA 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals, annual/seasonal, checked October 7, 2026.

If a step gets skipped

What goes wrong

⚠️

Planting before the first frost

Maine's bulletin says early planting can let the top come up above the soil, where it's prone to winter injury. In these states the planting week starts after the first frost, so an early frost means you're on time.

Source: University of Maine Extension, Bulletin #2063 Growing Hardneck Garlic in Your Maine Garden, checked October 9, 2026.

⚠️

Planting too shallow

Wisconsin says shallow cloves are prone to injury in winter and early spring. Measure the 2 to 3 inches to the base of the clove instead of guessing.

Source: University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026.

⚠️

Skipping the mulch, or packing it too heavy

Maine says mulch moderates the freeze and thaw cycles of the soil and the heaving of cloves. Wisconsin also warns against heavy mulch that keeps the soil from warming or wet soil from drying, and singles out wet leaves.

Source: University of Maine Extension, Bulletin #2063 Growing Hardneck Garlic in Your Maine Garden, checked October 9, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026.

⚠️

Ordering heads without checking cloves per head

Clove counts vary a lot. In a New Mexico trial, mean cloves per bulb ran from 5.5 to 15.9 across varieties. Break one head first and count before you order the rest.

Source: NMSU Research Report 717, Varietal Evaluation of Garlic in New Mexico, checked October 8, 2026.

A garlic bed covered with a thick layer of loose golden straw and frost on the lawn edge
Three to four inches of straw goes on the same week as the cloves.
Garlic planting time vs the first fall frost, zones 3 to 5 (NOAA 1991 to 2020) Nearest NOAA station to each zip code; zone from the 2023 USDA zip listing Bemidji, MN, zone 3bstation: Cass Lake typical Sep 261 in 10: Sep 12 Minnesota Extension: "one or two weeks after the first killing frost" St. Paul, MN, zone 5astation: U of MN St Paul typical Oct 81 in 10: Sep 25 Minnesota Extension: "one or two weeks after the first killing frost" Wausau, WI, zone 4bstation: Wausau Downtown Airport typical Oct 41 in 10: Sep 21 Wisconsin Extension: "within a week or two after the first killing frost" Madison, WI, zone 5astation: UW Arboretum - Madison typical Oct 91 in 10: Sep 26 Wisconsin Extension: "within a week or two after the first killing frost" Presque Isle, ME, zone 4astation: Presque Isle typical Sep 261 in 10: Sep 10 Maine Extension: "mid-September to the end of October, north to south" (whole state) Ames, IA, zone 5bstation: Ames Muni Airport typical Oct 81 in 10: Sep 23 Iowa State: "October to early November"; we draw early November as Nov 7 Sep 1Sep 15Oct 1Oct 15Nov 1Nov 15 1 to 2 weeks after the typical frostwindow as published typical first fall frost (32°F)1 in 10 earlier date
Each extension page's planting wording against the first fall frost at the NOAA station nearest a town in its state, 1991 to 2020 normals.
Fall garlic under mulch, then pulled back in spring (side view, to scale) Clove base 2 to 3 in down (Minnesota); 3 to 4 in of straw on top (Minnesota, Wisconsin) Fall: cover the whole bed Spring: pull it between the rows 3 to 4 in straw 2 to 3 in Fall: plant, then cover the bed the same week. Spring: rake it off the rows once hard freezes end, or leave it on until harvest (Maine).
Side view, drawn to scale: the whole bed under straw in fall, then the straw raked between the rows in spring.

When the steps change

Variants

🪴

Zone 3 or 4, far north

The rule stays the same; only the date moves. Near Bemidji, the Cass Lake station's typical first frost is September 26, so planting falls around October 3 to 10. Near Wausau it's October 4, so October 11 to 18.

Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026; NOAA 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals, annual/seasonal, checked October 7, 2026; PRISM 2023 USDA hardiness zone GIS datasets and zip-code listing, checked October 6, 2026.

🏙️

Maine

Maine's bulletin gives a calendar span instead of the frost rule: about mid-September to the end of October, north to south. Use the early end in the north of the state and the late end in the south.

Source: University of Maine Extension, Bulletin #2063 Growing Hardneck Garlic in Your Maine Garden, checked October 9, 2026.

❄️

Iowa and zone 5b

Iowa State says October to early November and uses 4 to 6 inches of straw, moved between the rows in early spring. At the Ames station the typical first frost is October 8.

Source: Iowa State Extension, When should I plant garlic?, checked October 8, 2026; NOAA 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals, annual/seasonal, checked October 7, 2026; PRISM 2023 USDA hardiness zone GIS datasets and zip-code listing, checked October 6, 2026.

☀️

Missed the fall window

Iowa State lists late March to mid-April as a spring planting time. The bulbs will be smaller, Maine says, so put fall planting on next year's calendar.

Source: Iowa State Extension, When should I plant garlic?, checked October 8, 2026; University of Maine Extension, Bulletin #2063 Growing Hardneck Garlic in Your Maine Garden, checked October 9, 2026.

What people learn the second year

Tips and tricks

  • Clear the bed before the frost. Pull the old plants and loosen the soil in late September. When the frost comes, all that's left is planting.
  • Write down the real frost. The lookup gives a 30-year normal. Note the night your own yard first frosts this fall and count the week from that. (NOAA 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals, annual/seasonal)
  • Mark the stick. Cut a stick to 6 inches and mark 3 inches on it. It sets both the spacing and the deepest planting depth.
  • Count the cloves in one head first. Break one head before you order the rest. If it has more or fewer than the six to eight Kentucky uses, redo the head count. (University of Kentucky Extension, October is garlic planting time)
  • Label the rows. Under 4 inches of straw every row looks the same. Put a tall tag at the start of each variety. (University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens)

The one we checked the steps against

Primary source

Growing garlic in home gardens, University of Minnesota Extension. Checked October 8, 2026.

University of Minnesota Extension writes for zones 3 to 5. Its garlic page gives the timing rule this plan is built on (one or two weeks after the first killing frost), the 2 to 3 inch depth to the base of the clove, the 3 to 4 inches of leaf or straw mulch, and the spring choice to remove it or leave it on.

The arithmetic and the background reading

Tools and guides in this system

Common questions

Questions

When should I plant garlic in zone 5?

One or two weeks after the first killing frost, Minnesota and Wisconsin Extension say. At the St. Paul and Madison stations that's mid to late October.

Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026; NOAA 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals, annual/seasonal, checked October 7, 2026.

When should I plant garlic in zone 3 or 4?

By the same rule, from an earlier frost date. Near Bemidji that's about October 3 to 10, and near Wausau October 11 to 18.

Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; NOAA 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals, annual/seasonal, checked October 7, 2026.

How deep do I plant garlic in a cold zone?

With the base of the clove 2 to 3 inches below the surface, pointed side up, Minnesota says. Wisconsin warns that shallow cloves can be injured over winter.

Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026.

How much straw do I put on garlic?

3 to 4 inches, Minnesota and Wisconsin say. For a 4 x 8 ft bed that's 8 to 10.7 cubic feet.

Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026.

When do I take the straw off garlic?

Minnesota and Wisconsin say after the threat of hard freezes is over, so the soil warms. Minnesota also allows leaving it on, and a 2021 Maine answer leaves it until harvest.

Source: University of Minnesota Extension, Growing garlic in home gardens, checked October 8, 2026; University of Wisconsin Extension, Garlic (A3785), checked October 9, 2026; University of Maine Extension, Is it too early to pull the mulch off my garlic plants?, checked October 8, 2026.

The next job on the shelf

More garden systems

Sources

Planning guide, not a guarantee. See every source on the site on the sources page. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Photos: Roger Starnes Sr / Unsplash